Home Substitutes 9 Best Substitutes For Allspice Berries

9 Best Substitutes For Allspice Berries

Allspice Berries are spicy spices that are present in a variety of dishes. This spicy spice is also known as Jamaican pepper and myrtle pepper. However, despite its name, it is also found in Mexico, Guatemala, Honduras, and other tropical climates.

At first bite, Allspice Berries are very spicy and taste hot. Not only hot, Allspice Berries also have a very strong aroma. Although not a spice mix, it is packed with distinct flavors of nutmeg, clove, cinnamon, and has a taste similar to ginger and pepper.

Although Allspice Berries are very useful in a variety of cuisines, their availability is limited and not always available. So when there is no availability of Allspice Berries, then you must use the best substitute for Allspice Berries. Here we will describe some suitable substitutes for Allspice Berries.

As we noted that some of the best substitutes for Allspice Berries are cloves, cinnamon, whole allspice fruit, nuts, cinnamon, star anise, etc. Ok, just look at the following explanation.

Best Substitutes For Allspice Berries

1. Whole Allspice Berries

These are whole Allspice Berries that can be a great substitute, if you don’t find ground fruit, you can grind it yourself.

If you need 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon of Allspice Berries powder, you will need to grind about 6 Allspice Berries. To grind it, you can use a pepper mill, spice grinder, or coffee grinder.

If you wish, you can also use whole Allspice Berries, but before serving, you must set them aside or remove them from your diet.

2. Nutmeg

Best Substitutes For Allspice Berries

Nutmeg is also one of the best substitutes for Allspice Berries, this spice has a warm taste, not spicy, to replace 1/2 teaspoon of Allspice Berries, you have to grind 1/4 teaspoon of ground nutmeg. If you haven’t found a similar taste, you can add back according to taste.

Nutmeg flavor is stronger and to replace Allspice Berries, you only need to add a little bit of ground nutmeg. If you need 1/2 ground Allspice Berries for a recipe, when replacing them with nutmeg you can simply add 1/4 or half of the amount.

3. Cloves

Cloves are also one of the best substitutes for allspice berries. The taste is stronger than the taste of allspice berries, so when using it you have to be careful and only use half of the ground allspice berries. If the taste is not right, you can add a little at a time.

When making sweet baked goods, adding cloves is great for replacing the sometimes available allspice berries. The two are not the same in taste, but when added to a sweet grilled dish, it is very tasty.

4. Cinnamon

The best substitute for allspice berries is cinnamon. If you use powdered allspice berries in your cooking, you may need ground cinnamon as a substitute. Cinnamon is known to be a very good substitute for ground or powdered allspice berries.

If your recipe calls for whole allspice berries, then you can substitute a few cinnamon sticks.

Usually recipes that use allspice berries also include cinnamon. So, if you replace allspice berries with cinnamon, add more cinnamon powder than allspice berries use in the recipe.

5. Five-Spice Powder

This powder has a warm, spicy and sweet taste and is similar to allspice berries. It is a mixture of several spices such as cinnamon, star anise, cloves, pepper, ginger and fennel.

In recipes that use allspice berries, you can replace them with five-spice powder.

6. Pumpkin Pie Spice + Pepper

Pumpkin Pie Spice + Pepper

One of the best substitutes for allspice berries is pumpkin pie spice plus pepper. This powder contains allspice berries and several other ingredients such as ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

So when you need a substitute for allspice berries, pumpkin pie spice can be the best alternative.

To get a savory taste you can add black pepper along with pumpkin pie spice.

7. Star Anise

Star Anise is another option to replace allspice. But Star Anise has a stronger taste, not only that, it also has a distinctive smell. So, when you use star anise as a substitute, you should consider this distinctive taste.

For some people the distinctive taste of star anise is sometimes too strong to replace allspice. So, this is not the best alternative, unless you are in an emergency.

8. Homemade Spice Blend

Homemade Spice Blend

Allspice is not a mix of many spices, but when you are having a hard time finding allspice for your recipe, you can combine several spices to produce a similar taste.

To get the best substitute for allspice berries, you can combine several spices such as 3 1/2 teaspoons of cinnamon powder, a pinch of cloves, and substitute in a ratio of 1:1.

You might also like:

9. Apple Pie Spice

As we said at the beginning, getting allspice berries is sometimes difficult. If you are in this condition, then you can choose one of the best substitutes for allspice above. If that’s not what you find, you can use another allspice substitute, this is Apple Pie Spice. It’s great for desserts and drinks if your recipe calls for allspice berries.

Apple Pie Spice

You can use the same ratio as using allspice berries.


What Does Allspice Taste Like?

If you ask “What Does Allspice Taste Like”, this spice might be said to be similar to other warm spices such as cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg. Spices or spices with a spicy taste are called allspice, which is why sometimes spices such as cinnamon and nutmeg can also replace them.

How Long Does Allspice Last?

Allspice berries can lose their aroma if left too long. So if you use allspice as a spice in your cooking, you should know how long allspice lasts.

Ground allspice should be used within two years, otherwise it will lose its taste. While whole allspice is more durable, you can use it for 3 or 4 years. To retain the taste, you must store allspice in a dark place that is not exposed to light.

Where Can I Buy Allspice?

If you don’t know where to get allspice, maybe this can help you.

You can buy this spice at a spice store or at a dry seasoning store.

Whole allspice berries are similar to dried peppercorns, so when buying them you should check carefully, so that you are really buying allspice berries and not peppercorns. You can buy whole allspice or powdered allspice, this depends on what spices you use most often in cooking.